John O'Brien has lived and thoroughly researched the Appalachian label. This book is a "must read" for any native of WV that wonders why they don't feel like an "Appalachian" and yet have been referred to as such. It is also the story of a young man fighting "Appalachian fatalism". It can be seen as a struggle against and a struggle for West Virginian culture. A great first book.

As a resident of Pendleton County during the first 22 years of my life, I have discovered through the writing of John O'Brien why I harbor an intense pride of my home state. A must read for anyone who has lived in the beautiful mountain state, anyone who has traveled there, or anyone who is curious about Appalachia. Beautifully and simply written, with historical facts and interspersed with personal vignettes.

This is a terrific book. O'Brien writes with a compelling style that could almost classify the book as a page turner (which is quite rare for this type of non fiction).

As a native West Virginian, just about every chapter had something that I strongly identified with...the West Virginia style family reunion in Pocahontas County, the "deep family secrets" that only the women talk about, the strong sense of family and community, the love of the outdoors, etc.

Growing up in Northern West Virginia, I always considered (and still do) my childhood to be somewhat idyllic. It was small town life with football, 4-H camp, camping vacations, spending summers at my grandmother's farm, etc. I was always puzzled as an adult after I had moved out of the state for graduate school at the quizzical/sorrowful looks that I would receive from people when I told them of my native state. John O'Brien has clearly articulated the history and reasons behind those stereotypes and I believe debunked most of the unfair ones.

I would recommend this book to any West Virginian (both resident and expat) who has that strong sense of pride in their heritage, but is searching for answers and explanations about the conflicting messages they receive from "the outside".

My only trepidation in this whole thing is that it took John O'Brien so long to write this first book, that another book from him may be a long time in coming.

Progressing from his study of slaveholding in Western North Carolina (Mountain Masters) and other explorations of Southern Appalachian History, John Inscoe has teamed up with Gordon B. McKinney, the editor of the microfilm version of the Zebulon B. Vance Papers and author of Southern Mountain Republicans to produce the first scholarly synthesis of the Civil War in Western North Carolina. The book breaks new ground in relying on the scholarship of the past twenty years to revise the portrait of a part of North Carolina that was considered to be staunchly Unionist. It explores mountaineers attitudes toward slavery, secession, and the war in general in very broad strokes; these insights are fleshed out with details from specific locales. From the historian's point of view, the authors have not met the rigorous burden of proof in many cases, choosing to base their conclusions on just one or two primary sources; in some cases, they are forced to draw from examples outside of the region (such as Tennessee) which would fail to satisfy the most demanding of those who want conclusive evidence. However, the book is a wonderful tale and in many cases shows the myriad of responses to what has been described as the most influential historical event in United States History.

I don't get the feeling McCoy has actually tried a lot of the things she writes about here. A similar Llewellyn offering, Silver Ravenwolf's HexCraft/American Folk Magic, was, at least, based partly on the author's own experiences using the methods described in the book; McCoy, on the other hand, appears to have written a long research paper presented in a pretty cover.

There isn't much in here that can't be found in other sources. Vance Randolph's Ozark Mountain Magic and Folklore [title?] is more interesting and was all collected firsthand from mountain people living in the 1930s and 40s. I suggest that those who are interested in American folk magic pick that one up instead, or take a look at Ravenwolf's book. This one is pretty much just a collection of secondhand material.

This book is a great introduction to Appalachian folklore from a witch's perspective, however as a book on useful magic it falls a little short. The author's attitude seems best conveyed with the paraphrased quote "when i decided to write a book on appalachia, i had no idea i'd have to dig through dozens of rare or out of print books," Indeed, with just a little effort, more practical magic can be dug up from the region, which the author didn't even visit to write this book. Furthermore, i was especially disapointed by the chapter on "death, dying, and haints" in relation to the original title of this book _In a Graveyard at Midnight_ (but then i own a newer edition and perhaps info was taken out when they changed the title?). The book _Albion's Seed_ does a better job of showing appalachia's cultural roots in scotland and northern england. Still, i have to give _Mountain Magic_ 3 stars because of McCoy's treatment of the Appalachian region and it's people.(of whom, i count myself to be among) Though she does romanticize the area's celtic roots a bit, she definately portrays the settlers of past and present in a good light, does alot to dispell mythes about hillbillies, and explains exactly why the mountains are the way they are. Most importantly of all, however, she raises a very good point, even if she doesn't elaborate on it too well, that one does not need to look to ireland or the brittish isles to find magic, or even celtic and anglo-saxon culture, but that perhaps the best place to look for these things is in our roots right here beneath our American feet.

Edain McCoy, a descent of the famous Kentucky family who feuded with the Hatfields, is an alumna of the University of Texas and studied for her graduate degree in Cultural History at Indiana University. She is the author of several reference books on Pagan and spiritual subjects and is also a practicing Wiccan.

She knows her subject well.

Appalachia was first populated by the Cherokee Indians, then came the Spanish explorers, and much later the English, Scots and Irish, many of them bringing with them the stern religious teachings of their native lands mingled with a sprinkling of pre-Christian Celtic beliefs.

McCoy's Mountain Magick paints a relevant picture of the folk beliefs still found in parts of Appalachia, and it is written with humor and compassion. It is a valuable record of the old ways and the wisdom from a part of the country modern times has, for the most part, passed by.

Here you will learn the signs the country people use to predict weather and garden; spells for love and self-protection and simple remedies still used in this land where doctors are too few and not always trusted. McCoy also includes magical spells to aid in fertility and divination, recipes used and other insightful information about the area and the unique people who live here.

Mountain Magick is a valuable resource for anyone interested in learning about Appalachia and its people.